What Kind of SJW Are You?

I’m not one to say I told you so (OK, maybe I am) but the recent Facebook scandal has illustrated the very concerns I have been sharing for years. Social networking has exploded in the past decade with people connecting and interacting on various platforms such as Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram, and of course, Facebook, sharing their daily lives, their ideas, dreams, concerns, dinner plans, etc. During the whole process, cries of privacy and safety concerns have come from many corners since all of the sharing reveals data that criminals could use to target new victims. The obvious culprits are pedophiles, burglars, and identity thieves, but this latest controversy has identified the real danger: data mining. The data comes from not only the profiles users build but also from user activities online, such as those inane quizzes that come across your Facebook feed. I have warned people about taking these quizzes for years.

When anyone sets up a social media account, the site requires a lot of information that seems quite logical to build a profile. Name, email, phone number, and birth date seem like reasonable information to build a profile, so people readily give up this info. But data mining sites don’t stop there. They want more. The reason they want more is not [just] to make the site more usable, but to make more money. Social networking sites sell user data to various marketing firms to generate revenue that keeps the site running. Users get ads that are targeted to them based on the information they share on social media sites. The more data provided by the user, the more targeted that ad.

The profile is not the only way that data gets collected, user activity actually provides way more data for these firms. Online quizzes ask seemingly innocuous questions that generate tons of data. These quizzes offer to let the user know what the user’s color says about them, what super hero they would be, and what their name means in Elvish among other things, and people clamor to give up their private information. Not only do they willingly do this, they also give up access to their online friend’s profiles. The data mining firms are cleaning up with all the data they have available and the marketing firms are loving sending specific ads so they can charge more to the advertisers. All this comes from those innocuous social profiles.

Now the media is up in arms about how user data has been collected supposedly to effect the presidential election. First it was Russian collusion, now it is Cambridge Analytica that ruined the Clinton presidency that the media had prepared to celebrate. The real fact of the matter is that Cambridge Analytica did nothing more than any other data firm has been doing since the birth of the Internet. They collected data and sold that data.

Was Facebook complicit in this supposed breech of public trust? Yes and no. They created the platform that makes such interaction possible and they built the system that sells the data to pay for it. Did Mark Zuckerberg set out to ruin Hillary’s presidential chances? Of course not. That was just a bonus.

Now the internet’s social justice warriors are promoting the hashtag #deletefacebook to call on users to quit the social media giant as a form of punishment. These people think that since their data—that they happily gave up on their own—was used in a way that they don’t like, the site that collected that data must be shut down.

It is just another example of how society refuses to accept any personal responsibility for their actions. They gave up the data willingly. Once you give it up, what it is used for is no longer your concern. You don’t want Cambridge Analytica to sell your data, don’t take the stupid online quizzes.

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Media, Society, Technology

One response to “What Kind of SJW Are You?

  1. Anonymous

    Well said. I too, when first exploring the internet (World Wide Web) knew how much tracking of users could be done, but I felt like a kid in a candy store. IT WAS THE BIGGEST encyclopaedia EVER. An infinite card catalogue, with pictures! Hours and hours at the university’s 9 or 10 internet connected computers at the writing center, put me into a realm I had never imagined before 1996. I was obsessed.
    Forget word processors for my writing, I couldn’t live and breathe or graduate without access to the internet. Poor little portable IBM Selectric, once the highest tech writing tool, who so faithfully accompanied me to two universities, & before that, high school even, went by the wayside.

    Thus, the annoyingly spooky pop-ups didn’t bother me too much. I understood marketing and advertising well enough. My sister in law worked for a large data company, who had already been mining data for at least 20 years. I thought it brilliant to target a consumer.

    It’s simply a convenient work tool and commerce booster. Big Brother in a Brown Bag.

    I balked at first, to join Fake Book, but my little sister wanted me too, “so she can keep track” of me…both my teen aged daughters loved it and we could swap pics, so in 2010, I think it was, I did it. But I used an abbreviated form of my name, imagined credentials and info which wouldn’t identify me so specifically.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s